Should I buy the Eufy Smart Scale P3 or Withings Body Smart?

Choosing between the Eufy Smart Scale P3 and the Withings Body Smart mostly comes down to what you value most: the scale hardware, the app experience, and whether you care about any optional paid features.

My short take

• Buy the Eufy Smart Scale P3 if you want a colorful display, a more visually engaging scale, and a simpler no-friction experience.
• Buy the Withings Body Smart if you want a more polished health-tracking ecosystem and are okay with a more app-centered approach.

Why I’d lean each way

Eufy Smart Scale P3

• Good if you want the scale itself to show useful info clearly.
• A strong pick if you prefer a value-oriented option with a straightforward experience.
• If avoiding subscription paywalls matters to you, Eufy is generally the safer pick.

Withings Body Smart

• Good if you want a more refined health-tracking experience.
• Better fit if you care about ecosystem integration and a more premium app experience.
• Some deeper insights may depend on the app/service setup, so it’s worth checking what’s included before buying.

Bottom line

If you want the more screen-forward, simple option, go Eufy P3. If you want the more polished health-platform experience, go Withings Body Smart.

One important caveat: body-composition measurements from smart scales are still estimates based on bioelectrical impedance, so treat them as trend data rather than clinical measurements. Also, exact feature sets and app access can change, so it’s worth checking the current product pages before buying.