Should I buy the Nespresso Vertuo Pop or Keurig K-Supreme?

Choosing between the Nespresso Vertuo Pop and the Keurig K-Supreme mostly comes down to coffee style and pod cost.

Short verdict

• Choose the Nespresso Vertuo Pop if you want a coffee maker that can do espresso-style drinks and richer coffee, with the crema Nespresso is known for.
• Choose the Keurig K-Supreme if you want standard drip-style coffee, lower-cost pods, and the broad convenience of K-Cups being easy to find in stores.

Key differences

1. Coffee style: The Vertuo Pop is built around Nespresso’s barcode-based system, which automatically adjusts brewing for different Vertuo pods. The K-Supreme is aimed at regular single-serve coffee rather than espresso-style drinks.
2. Pod cost and availability: K-Cups are usually cheaper and far more widely available. Nespresso Vertuo pods tend to cost more and have a more limited selection.
3. Convenience/features: The K-Supreme is simple to use and has brew-strength options. The Vertuo Pop is very automated once you insert a pod.

Bottom line

If you drink mostly coffee, go with the Keurig K-Supreme. If you want better-tasting espresso-style drinks and don’t mind paying more per pod, go with the Nespresso Vertuo Pop.

One caveat: the Vertuo system is much more proprietary than Keurig, so pod choices are more limited than with K-Cups. Exact features and pod availability can vary by model and retailer, so it’s worth checking the current product pages before buying.