QUESTION

Should I buy a used Apple Magic Trackpad or Logitech MX Anywhere 3S?

13 upvotes0 downvotes

Asked May 30, 2026Last updated June 14, 2026Answers can change over time.

Answer80% confidence

Buy the used Apple Magic Trackpad if you mainly use a Mac or iPad and care about gestures, scrolling, Mission Control/App Exposé-style navigation, or a laptop-like feel. Buy the Logitech MX Anywhere 3S if you want a compact, precise mouse that works well across desks, travel, and non-Apple setups.

My pick for most Apple-device users: used Apple Magic Trackpad, assuming the condition and battery are good. It gives you the macOS/iPadOS gesture experience that a mouse can’t fully replace. If you do lots of spreadsheet, CAD, gaming, or click-and-drag precision work, choose the MX Anywhere 3S instead.

Our pick

Apple Magic Trackpad

Best for mac and iPad gesture users

Maars picked this for Mac and iPad users who want gesture-first navigation: it feels closest to a built-in MacBook trackpad on a desktop.

Search on eBay

At a glance

Side-by-side comparison

Swipe to compare

	Used Magic Trackpad	MX Anywhere 3S
Best choice if you use	Mac or iPad gestures heavily	A mouse across work, travel, or mixed setups
Navigation feel	Large touch surface with swipes and multi-finger gestures	Traditional mouse pointer control with physical buttons
Precision work	Good for general use, but less ideal for long click-and-drag sessions	Better for precise pointing, selecting, dragging, and compact desk setups
Used-buy risk	Higher: check battery, surface, click feel, charging, and pairing	Lower if buying new; if used, still check scroll wheel, buttons, and battery
Main reason to choose it	You want the Apple gesture experience	You want a portable, precise mouse

Also compared

Search on Amazon

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Best for portable mouse users

Maars picked this for people who want a compact mouse with precise control: it is the more practical choice for travel, small desks, and pointer-heavy work.

Search on Amazon

Alternatives

A trackpad plus a compact mouse can be a strong setup: trackpad for gestures and browsing, mouse for precision work.
Buy both used if prices are low
They solve different problems rather than being perfect substitutes.
Consider buying new if the used Magic Trackpad has unknown battery health, visible surface damage, or a price close to new.
Buy new instead of used
A worn trackpad can be frustrating, and savings may not justify the risk.

What could change this answer

Used Magic Trackpad battery health and charging behavior can change the value a lot.
Your main device setup matters: Mac/iPad use favors the trackpad, Windows or mixed-device use favors the mouse.
Current prices and condition of the used unit could outweigh the feature advantages.

Found this helpful?

More buying options

May include affiliate links

Search Amazon Search eBay

Our pick

Apple Magic Trackpad

Best for mac and iPad gesture users

Maars picked this for Mac and iPad users who want gesture-first navigation: it feels closest to a built-in MacBook trackpad on a desktop.

Search on eBay

At a glance

Side-by-side comparison

Swipe to compare

	Used Magic Trackpad	MX Anywhere 3S
Best choice if you use	Mac or iPad gestures heavily	A mouse across work, travel, or mixed setups
Navigation feel	Large touch surface with swipes and multi-finger gestures	Traditional mouse pointer control with physical buttons
Precision work	Good for general use, but less ideal for long click-and-drag sessions	Better for precise pointing, selecting, dragging, and compact desk setups
Used-buy risk	Higher: check battery, surface, click feel, charging, and pairing	Lower if buying new; if used, still check scroll wheel, buttons, and battery
Main reason to choose it	You want the Apple gesture experience	You want a portable, precise mouse

Also compared

Search on Amazon

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Best for portable mouse users

Maars picked this for people who want a compact mouse with precise control: it is the more practical choice for travel, small desks, and pointer-heavy work.

Search on Amazon

Alternatives

A trackpad plus a compact mouse can be a strong setup: trackpad for gestures and browsing, mouse for precision work.
Buy both used if prices are low
They solve different problems rather than being perfect substitutes.
Consider buying new if the used Magic Trackpad has unknown battery health, visible surface damage, or a price close to new.
Buy new instead of used
A worn trackpad can be frustrating, and savings may not justify the risk.

What could change this answer

Used Magic Trackpad battery health and charging behavior can change the value a lot.
Your main device setup matters: Mac/iPad use favors the trackpad, Windows or mixed-device use favors the mouse.
Current prices and condition of the used unit could outweigh the feature advantages.

Found this helpful?

More buying options

May include affiliate links

Search Amazon Search eBay

Should I buy a used Apple Magic Trackpad or Logitech MX Anywhere 3S?

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Tags

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Tags

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Apple Magic Trackpad

Side-by-side comparison

Logitech MX Anywhere 3S

Alternatives

What could change this answer

Ask Maars another question

Related questions

Tags

Ask Maars another question

Related questions