Should I buy a used Scion iM or Toyota Corolla Hatchback?

If your budget allows, the Toyota Corolla Hatchback is usually the better buy. The Scion iM — later sold as the Toyota Corolla iM — is a dependable, budget-friendly commuter, but the Corolla Hatchback is the newer, more refined choice overall.

Why the Corolla Hatchback is usually the better choice:

• Newer design and generally more polished feel: It’s the newer generation, so it typically feels more modern in everyday driving.
• More power: The Corolla Hatchback’s 2.0L engine makes 168 horsepower, which is a noticeable step up from the iM’s 137-hp 1.8L engine.
• Better tech and safety availability: Used Corolla Hatchbacks are more likely to come with newer infotainment and driver-assist features than the older iM.

When the Scion iM / Corolla iM makes more sense:

• Lower purchase price: If you want the cheapest reliable option, the older iM is often the better value.
• Practical packaging: The iM’s boxier shape can make the cabin and cargo area feel useful.

Bottom line:

Pick the Corolla Hatchback if you want the newer, stronger, more modern option. Pick the Scion iM / Corolla iM if saving money matters more and you’re okay with an older car.

A few details can vary by model year and trim, so it’s worth checking the exact vehicle’s feature list before buying. Because the Scion iM was only sold for the 2016 model year before becoming the Corolla iM, any Scion iM you find today will be quite old. A pre-purchase inspection is a smart idea either way.